Irrational exuberance describes a state of unfounded market optimism where asset prices rise to unsustainable levels, driven by psychological factors rather than fundamental economic value. It is often associated with the speculative bubbles that precede major market crashes. – Alan Greenspan
Suppose you think of the preseason predictions for Texas’ 2025 football season as a marketable financial asset. Do you believe the underlying fundamentals justify its current value as the consensus preseason number one team? I’m not so sure. I think the Texas brand and Arch Manning mania are psychological factors that may have inflated Texas’s asset value into a speculative bubble that cannot be sustained.
Let’s take a look at some key fundamentals I’m concerned about that create value for a football team.
1. Quarterback: Arch Manning will be in his first year as a full-time starter in college football. I think Manning will be good, potentially great, based on his performance filling in for Quinn Ewers last season. However, it’s fair to weigh that performance against the mediocre competition it came against in UTSA, Louisiana-Monroe, and Mississippi State. Having a first-year starter at quarterback is not usually a recipe for competing for a national championship, Trevor Lawrence aside.
Prognosis
OK, I’m not really concerned about our quarterback. I saw enough last year to make me believe Manning will be the strength of this team and make us wonder why the hell he wasn’t starting last season after Quinn Ewers’ injury.
2. Offensive line: As the offensive line goes, so goes the team. That’s been my simplified way to judge how good the teams I root for will be. Therefore, it would seem problematic for Texas to have four new starters this season. Maybe not. Texas’s offensive line last season turned out to be the most overrated unit in Texas football for as long as I can remember. This unit, thought to be the best in the country at the start of the season, couldn’t provide any push against Georgia twice and Ohio State. Texas’ combined rushing total for those three games was 116 yards. Still, three of the starters were drafted in the 2025 draft, and Kelvin Banks was selected in the first round. Has anybody wondered if the much-praised offensive line coach, Kyle Flood, is as overrated as the 2025 offensive line was?
This year’s offensive line features Trevor Goosby at left tackle, replacing Kelvin Banks. Goosby started two games last year and appeared in 15. Though just a redshirt sophomore, Goosby is projected to be a first-round NFL draft pick in 2026. The one returning starter is senior right guard DJ Campbell, who has been the starter since the 2023 season. Campbell, in a rare exception for an offensive lineman, hasn’t had the benefit of a redshirt season. Veteran Cole Huston replaces Jake Majors at center. Can anybody tell me how Majors got to play 10 seasons in college? 😊
Sophomore Brandon Baker is projected to start at right tackle. Neto Umeozulu, a fourth-year junior, will start at left guard.
After last year’s disappointing season for the much-ballyhooed offensive line, it’s hard to have a lot of confidence in this remade unit.
Prognosis
I am not a Kyle Flood believer. I’ll be pleasantly surprised if this unit is above average.
3. Interior defensive line
Texas could suffer the most significant drop-off on the interior of the defensive line from 2024. Last season’s starters, Vernon Broughton and Alfred Collins, were 2025 NFL draft picks. Bill Norton, a rotational defensive tackle, signed with the Los Angeles Rams as an undrafted free agent.
To replace these players, Texas turned to the transfer portal. Cole Brevard is a transfer from Purdue, where he earned Honorable Mention All-Big 10 honors. His role is run stopper. Maraad Watson is a transfer from Syracuse, where he was a Freshman All-American in 2024. It’s a good sign that Texas beat out Georgia, Miami, Tennessee, and Ohio State to land him. Hero Kanu is a transfer from Ohio State. He has only played two years of football after moving to the United States. The scouting report says he’s a physical freak that needs development.
Prognosis
Texas’ defensive staff proved last year that they’re good at picking transfers for these positions, so I’m taking a leap of faith and betting this unit will hold up their end of the bargain.
4. Field Goal Kicker
It appears that Mason Shipley, a transfer from Texas State, has won the job. Shipley has kicked for three years for Texas State and has made 31 of 35 field goal attempts with a long of 60 yards. That’s a good track record, but Bert Auburn had a good track record before 2024.
Prognosis
Everyone knows kickers are crazy, so who knows?
5. Red Zone Offense
Now my broken heart
Cries for you each night (cries for you each night)
And it’s almost like a song (almost like a song)
But it’s much too sad to write
— Archie Paul Jordan and Hal David
Red zone offense may be the biggest challenge for Steve Sarkisian’s football team, but it is too sad to write about, so I’ll summarize my thoughts.
Sarkisian has to change the way he does business to turn this area around. To solve Texas’s red zone issues, I believe Sarkisian needs to hire a real offensive coordinator. Sark can be a head coach or an offensive coordinator. He can’t be both. In my opinion, until he gets this his red zone woes will continue. Furthermore, he can’t be the head coach and the offensive coordinator and win the national championship.
Conclusion
The Longhorns are loaded in areas not discussed here: running back, wide receiver, edge rusher, linebacker, and defensive back. This is why I believe Texas is currently overvalued. The positions are important and can compensate for some of the concerns I have pointed out. But this isn’t flag football. You can’t live on glamor positions alone.
Ohio State
What agreat way to start a season. I doubt Steve Sarkisian and Ryan Day feel the same way. The loser of this game will be forgiven if they win 10 games or more during the regular season. But the team that wins will gain a larger margin of error for its next 11 regular-season games.
Willie Earl Exclusive
The expert writers covering the Longhorns are paying a lot of attention to Ohio State’s new defensive coordinator, Matt Patricia. Patricia is best known for being the defensive coordinator for the New England Patriots from 2012 to 2017. As a long-time Patriots fan who has followed them almost as closely as I’ve followed the Longhorns, here is my in-depth opinion of Matt Patricia.
He’s a lazy dufus retread who’s greatest claim to fame is being Bill Belichick’s yes man.
Go Horns and beat the hell outta Ohio State!
Hook ‘Em,
W.E.
We lost a couple of good friends way too early this summer.
For Mike Yoxall and John Scott
It was reported that during the second to last scrimmage that the No. 1 defense had its way with that new Offensive line. Hope like hell there has been improvement. It is the single-biggest key to a Longhorn win or defeat.
And, great song pick; didn’t know Hal David was involved, but it IS one of my faves as sung by Ronnie Milsapp.
I was counting on a sober account from Willie Earl. High expectations are a dangerous thing—for anyone but especially a football team. I just rewatched Friday Night Lights, movie version with Billy Bob, and there’s your lesson in Texas football expectations. Still, goddamn, we want these Horns to deliver, if only to get those obnoxious Buckeye fans to cry into their meatloaf. “Ohio against the world.” Please.
Glad you returned Willie Earl! You were missed
My son Paul married a sweet Longhorn, Kate. They bought 4 season tickets to UT football.
Looking forward to watching Manning this year.