Slow Down

A friend, who is a golfer and Longhorn fan, asked me the other day if Arch Manning was in the middle of a swing change. For those who aren’t golfers, my friend was ironically comparing Manning’s passing struggles to those of a golfer who is struggling after changing his swing. Professional golfers and even double-digit handicappers like me, looking for long-term improvement, often change their swings under the guidance of coaches. In the short term, transitioning to a new swing can be awkward and frustrating with poor results until the player gains confidence in his new swing.

Like my friend, I too was thinking of Manning’s passing struggles in terms of golf, but I had a slightly different take on the golf analogy. When golfers are playing poorly, it’s frequently because, in their nervousness, they are swinging too fast. When I’m struggling during a round, slowing down my swing is my go-to move in trying to play better. It often works!

From Manning’s first incompletion of the season in the Ohio State game to many of his 14 incompletions versus UTEP, Manning is rushing his throws like a golfer swinging too fast. It’s so painfully obvious that I’m surprised Sarkisian, Arch’s father, uncles, or somebody hasn’t managed to get Manning to slow down.

My observations about Manning were validated by Joel Klatt when he appeared on Colin Cowherd’s show this week. Here is part of what he said. “Arch’s mechanics are not great right now. He’s playing faster than the timing of the offense.” He went on to explain that Texas is playing a West Coast offense from the passing game perspective. “In the West Coast system, from a football perspective, it goes by the equation timing plus spacing equals completions.” Arch is ahead of the spacing; he’s rushing, therefore the ball tends to nose-dive and be low or away.”

On a positive note, Klatt said that Manning is making good reads and good decisions about where to throw the ball. This is a big deal. We know Manning has the physical traits of being a good quarterback. It’s very possible, even likely in my opinion that eventually he’ll get the mechanics and timing down. The reason most quarterbacks fail in moving from high school to college and college to pro is that they are unable to learn to read defenses and make good decisions.

*****

Some college football commentators and fans, including Texas fans, should also slow down on their rush to judgment of Arch Manning and Texas’s prospects in 2025. Some are predicting an 8-4 or 7-5 season.  I’m as surprised as anyone that Manning has played this poorly through the first three games. Well, surprise, surprise, Manning isn’t the wunderkind he was almost universally predicted to be. Shocking that he is succumbing to the pressure of expectations and being the Texas quarterback. He’s virtually human-like!

Here’s my quick judgment on Manning and the Horns. As I mentioned earlier, I think Manning will improve his passing, and he will beat SEC opponents with both passing and running. He won’t win the Heisman Trophy or be a first-round NFL pick in 2026, but don’t be surprised if he makes second-team All-SEC in 2025. He will also return to Texas for the 2026 season.

***

Defense is an underappreciated commodity in college football. Texas fans should be more excited about a defense that will surrender fewer than 20 points per game in the SEC. The offensive line will hold back the offense, but the defense will lead to SEC wins for Texas by scores such as 24-13, 27-17, 34-10, and so on.

Does OU not suck?

I think Oklahoma is getting too much credit for beating Michigan. I caught glimpses of the game during a party at a restaurant, which Oklahoma won at home 24-13. I didn’t think it was a particularly well-played game on either side and Michigan still looks mediocre. Michigan quarterback Bryce Underwood reportedly is getting paid $3 million a year. He’s huge, listed at 6’ 4”, 228, and he looks bigger than that. But he’s raw and hasn’t been impressive yet.

Oklahoma’s quarterback John Mateer, a transfer from Washington State, passed for 270 yards versus Michigan and ran for 74. College football commentators David Pollack and Greg McElroy are touting Mateer as the best player in college football. Hmmn.

Oklahoma, 3-0, hosts Auburn on Saturday. Could be interesting.

Sam Houston State

I was surprised to learn that Sam Houston went 10-3 last season and won the Carriers New Orleans Bowl over Georgia Southern. Other victories were over Rice, Texas State, and UTEP.

Sadly, for the Bearkats, their roster was decimated by the transfer portal. This season, they are 0-3, losing to Western Kentucky, UNLV, and Hawaii. They were off last week, so they’ve had two weeks to rest and bone up for the Longhorns. Upset alert! 

Did you know that in 2027, Texas plays the Sam Houston Institute of Technology?

I make score predictions for Texas games two or three times a year. This game is one of them.

Texas over Sam Houston 59-9

W.E.

Just one song this week

Tags :
Share This :

One Response

  1. I believe Manning has the “yips,” like a golfer who almost can’t make himself take the club or putter back. He’s afraid of not being perfect. But quarterbacking, like golf, is not a game of perfect. I agree with our blog author that Manning eventually will get it together and become at least a top-3 SEC QB.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News

[iframe https://keepthescore.com/board/ghtycfngqjfle/ 1000 1200]