In my Monday post about reporting Over/Under results, I mentioned that I received more texts, emails, and phone calls from readers after the Kentucky game than for any other game I can remember, whether Texas had won or lost. The following are some of what the readers wrote or said, along with my responses. Some of the readers’ comments have been edited for clarity.
From an emailer:
Maybe you should write a paragraph for people like me, who had more than enough of Ewers last year, even down to his delivery of the football. I screamed at the TV to put in Manning, but guess what? Sark knew he wasn’t ready for prime time. Yes, he has talent, and he would be better with an occasional block up front —but even his decision-making at times is dubious. We complain a lot about Sark, saying he needs an offensive coordinator and that he should have done this or that, but he knows his players, particularly his QBs. We could do a lot worse at HC- look at all the musical chairs going on mid-season.
I, too, thought Sarkisian should have replaced Ewers with Manning last year, and now consider that Sark knew last year that Ewers was better than Manning. But Manning started against Mississippi State—an SEC opponent—last year and went 26-31 for 325 yards and two touchdowns in a 35-13 win for Texas. Couple that passing performance with his running ability, which Ewers didn’t possess, and I think it was reasonable to believe at the time that Manning should be the starter.
This season, Manning has a clear case of the yips. Manning’s yips remind me of Chuck Knoblauch, a Gold Glove second baseman for the Yankees in the late nineties and early 2000s, who suddenly couldn’t accurately make routine throws of around 60-70 feet to first base, some of which went into the stands, derailing his career.
Regarding Sarkisian, I would tell the reader that I haven’t heard even his harshest critics suggest he should be fired. I believe Sarkisian needs to hire an offensive coordinator in the offseason. It’s too late for him to relinquish play-calling this season.
From a texter:
Manning is the worst Texas quarterback in history.
This reader is overreacting to Manning’s poor performance, probably because Manning hasn’t been the best quarterback in Texas history as the preseason hype suggested. Based on the flashes of talent that Manning has shown over the nine games he’s started, while not living up to the preseason hype, he can still develop into a good quarterback.
Regarding the preseason hype, for all the praise the Manning family receives, I think they contributed to it by accepting too many commercial endorsements for Arch. His overexposure exacerbates his struggles on the football field.
Another texter wrote:
Mike Leach said he would never recruit a quarterback who wasn’t accurate because it can’t be taught. I’m pretty sure now that Manning is simply inaccurate, and it can’t be fixed.
Manning was recruited by most, if not all, of the top programs in the country because one of his traits was accuracy. As I wrote above, I think Manning has the yips. He may get over them, he may not.
Teams know they can’t run now, so putting at least one extra guy into the pass rush is all that’s needed to either get Manning or make him throw even more poorly than he does when not under duress. The offense officially is moribund, if not simply dead.
I agree with this except for the last sentence. The offense was certainly moribund against Kentucky, but a week earlier, it was effective against Oklahoma. Against Oklahoma, Texas ran the ball effectively with outside-zone blocking. For some reason, Sarkisian’s game plan against Kentucky was gap-scheme blocking, which the offensive line has not executed successfully this season. Obviously, this was a mistake on Sark’s part. I expect we’ll see outside zone versus Mississippi State. Below is an AI explanation of zone versus gap scheme blocking.
The outside zone blocking scheme is a football offensive play in which linemen move laterally to create a horizontal stretch on the defense, forcing defenders to flow to one side and opening a cutback lane for the running back. Offensive linemen use zone-based techniques, focusing on reaching their designated zone rather than directly blocking a specific gap, as in a gap scheme. Key to the scheme is the running back’s vision to find the hole and the linemen’s ability to work together to seal the edge or create cutback opportunities.
More from the texter:
And I don’t care for Sarkisian’s petulance when asked a question by a reporter, last night after the game, or in his weekly Monday press conferences. He’s surly and disrespectful to people doing their jobs, while he makes $10 million a year. The only good news is he’ll be forced to get rid of Flood and Banks after the season goes 7-5, best-case scenario.
I don’t share the concern over Sarkisian’s dealings with the press. In my opinion, too many of the questions they ask are unanswerable, but they ask them anyway. Questions that are like, “When did you stop beating your wife?”
I agree that the offensive line coach, Kyle Flood, should be let go after the season. I don’t think Sarkisian would fire him unless he were forced to by those above him. I don’t know what the texter’s problem is with Jeff Banks, the special teams coach. Ryan Niblett is the second leading punt returner in the country, and the special teams unit as a whole is ranked 11th according to ESPN. Mason Shipley has been solid. In the Kentucky game, he and Ryan Niblett were the Horns’ saviors.
Another texter wrote:
Sarkisian totally bungled his appraisal of the talent he had on hand after last season, did little to nothing (kicker Shipley excepted) to restock.
This comment is on target concerning the offensive line. But Sarkisian deserves credit for getting solid defensive line replacements through the portal in, Maraad Watson (Syracuse), Lavon Johnson (Maryland), Hero Kanu (Ohio State), Travis Shaw (North Carolina), and Cole Brevard (Purdue).
On to Mississippi State
The consensus is that the Bulldogs are a vastly improved team from a year ago in head coach Jeff Lebby’s second season in Starkville. Paul Wadlington on Inside Texas wrote about the Bulldogs: They have a clear system and identity, and those are precisely the reasons they’ve gone from a 2-10 team to a respectable 4-3 club in one offseason.
Mississippi State has a signature win over Arizona State in Starkville. They lost at home in overtime to Tennessee. They are 0-3 in the SEC, with losses to Texas A&M (31-9) and Florida (23-21), in addition to the loss to Tennessee.
Mississippi State Notes
Quarterback Blake Shapen is 24 years old.
Former Longhorn Brenen Thompson is their leading receiver with 533 yards and four touchdowns.
The defense leads the SEC in interceptions with 10.
Final Thought/wish
Many championship teams in history have won a game they should have lost on their way to a title.
Hook ‘Em,
W.E.
Banks is a money man, not a coach. Not needed with NIL. And yes, I agree that Manning has the yips like Knaublock (sp?). Said yips destroyed the baseball player’s career. I guess you assume Manning’s will abate. Not sure why either of us would assume they won’t or will. That said, I certainly don’t want him benched, results be damned. The Horns would never get a 5-star QB again (whether or not the 5-star rating is accurate).
As for Sarkisian’s petulance, he went 180-degrees in his Monday press conference and took responsibility for the team’s issues. Good for him. I wonder if Del Conte suggested he do so.