Arch Manning Overreaction Syndrome

I was out of town and didn’t have access to the UTSA game telecast, but Helen and I followed it via ESPN’s Gamecast. When Texas scored a touchdown early in the second quarter to go up 17-3, the game seemed to be unfolding as expected. An easy Texas win. At that point, I turned my attention to the Ole Miss-LSU game on television, so I didn’t see what I would hear about later: Arch Manning’s mediocre-to-bad performance throwing the football. After the game, I looked at the box score and saw Manning was 16-for-32, for 161 yards and two touchdowns. Not very good but not alarming from what I could see on paper.

Later that night, my son texted me Texas fans’ comments about Manning’s performance that he had seen in various forums. My favorite comment read: Manning is the worst Texas quarterback since Case McCoy. I laughed right out loud when I read it. The mere mention of Case McCoy always makes me laugh. A week after Manning led a nearly unprecedented fourth-quarter comeback against Ohio State, fans were freaking about him. What we have here is Arch Manning Overreaction Syndrome. We’ll call it AMOS going forward. Heck, even I was guilty of AMOS last week when I wrote that Arch had one hand on the Heisman. I didn’t really think that, but I thought it made good copy.

Manning’s play against UTSA was subpar, but couldn’t fans have anticipated that? It shouldn’t have been surprising to see a letdown after three straight games in near-100-degree heat, including an epic contest against Ohio State. In addition, it isn’t surprising that Manning may not have been at his best after the kerfuffle over his reaction to that AI-generated Holly Rowe video. Full disclosure, I haven’t seen the video, but I laughed when I read the description. Tell me, what 22-year-old hasn’t laughed at an inappropriate joke? People even criticized Manning for scrambling several times in the UTSA game. But isn’t it a good thing that when a quarterback isn’t seeing it in the passing game, he can make plays with his legs?

The History of AMOS

2019

In 2019, Arch Manning was a freshman and the starting quarterback for Isidore Newman High School’s varsity team, where he passed for more than 2,400 yards and 34 touchdowns. Impressive for any quarterback, but especially for a freshman. Before his freshman year was over, Manning received scholarship offers from SMU, LSU, Ole Miss, Georgia, and Alabama.

But Isidore Newman was a private school competing in the Texas equivalent of a 2A district, and  I’ve seen film of Manning from high school, as many of you have. He was throwing to wide-open receivers, and when he ran, I didn’t see many defenders trying to tackle him. I think it was an overreaction for colleges to offer a high school freshman.

2022

After Manning committed to Texas in June 2022, reports said he influenced four- and five-star recruits to sign with Texas, including wide receivers Johntay Cook and Ryan Wingo, running back Cedric Baxter, and offensive linemen Trevor Goosby and Andre Cojoe. Cook and Baxter are no longer with the team, and Andre Cojoe has appeared in seven games since 2023 and has never started. Obviously, Wingo and Goosby are outstanding players. Bottom line: Manning didn’t become a full-time starter until his third year in the program, and Texas fans are still waiting for the Manning Bunch—if you will —to produce a championship of any kind.

2025

The AP and Coaches poll ranked Texas #1 before the start of the 2025 season, even though Texas’s starting quarterback, Arch Manning, had previously started only two games. Texas didn’t qualify for the 12-team playoff.

Final Thoughts on AMOS

Put the Manning name together with the Texas Longhorns, and when Arch doesn’t instantly and consistently perform up to superstar expectations, you’re going to see wild swings in Texas fans’ reactions.

By now, we Texas fans have to accept that Arch isn’t going to be a superstar.

Tennessee

True freshman Faizon Brandon is Tennessee’s quarterback. He’s 6’4” and mobile, with plenty of speed and a good arm. Tennessee’s offense is a 2026 version of the Veer N Shoot, featuring formations with three running backs and/or tight ends in the backfield that Texas hasn’t seen before. They’re averaging 298 rushing yards per game, 4th in the country. On paper, this is frightening, but they haven’t faced a good team yet.

Jim Knowles is the Vols’ new defensive coordinator. He was the DC for Ohio State’s 2024 national championship. Last season, he was the DC for Penn State and the highest-paid assistant coach in college football.  His defense is holding opponents to 298 yards and 14 points per game. By contrast, Texas is giving up 288 yards and 12 points per game.

A breath of fresh air

The game-time temperature in Knoxville is forecast to be 64° with a game high of 76°.

Quote of the week from Paul Wadlington at “Inside Texas”

The battle for the real UT and the fight between burnt orange sunsets and school crossing-guard safety-vest orange. 😊

***

This looks like a tough first road game for the Horns. They’re favored by 4.5.

Hook ‘em,

W.E.

Willie Earl’s Top 40 Countdown

More than anything else, I’m a pop music fan. I make no pretense of having sophisticated musical tastes. To a great extent, my list is sentimental. After all, what is music if it’s not sentimental? 

Now on with the countdown

#30

#29

#28

Tags :
Share This :

4 Responses

  1. I always love when you refer to written words as “copy”. Arch is still slowly developing, no rush, just like uncle Peyton who surprised everyone by staying another year… don’t be surprised when Arch does the same. Horns win 30-16, all hail Muschamp.

  2. Re Arch Manning, and in the words of the esteemed Jed Clampett, “There’s somethin wrong with that boy.” On the one hand, his two TD passes were big-time NFL caliber. On the other hand, his misfires were beyond atrocious; high and wide with no pressure or drilled low and outside with no pressure. At least two of them were certain TDs with an average throw. So, here’s the deal: get used to wild up and downs in his game because Sarkisian sure as hell isn’t going to insert K.J. Lacy or Dia Bell in this or any of the rest of the games this season unless Manning goes down.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News

[iframe https://keepthescore.com/board/ghtycfngqjfle/ 1000 1200]